Here is what I have of:
Keep Christmas with you - Bob and the Kids (Christmas Eve on Sesame Street record)
Keep Christmas with you - The Entire Cast (Chrismtas Eve on Sesame Street record)
Keep Christmas with you - The Entie Cast (Christmas Eve on Sesame Street record) I guess it's also but it shows only two version are on the record. (the website that shows it) But when you listen it has David singing a part in the song. Where does this version go?
Keep Chrismtas with you (all through the years) - (Sing along Chrismtas Record) This one I don't know. I just know that David is not in this version. When I download the songs (from which I can't rememeber) I didn't either get this one or they didn't have it.
I don't have any of the record version or the renewed one (which I never cared about) But there are like five version counting the renewed one. This is what I came up with. Here is the website about all the SS records. Three are Christmas ones.
http://members.tripod.com/hooperfan/Music.html/Albums.html