1. Welcome to the Muppet Central Forum!
    You are viewing our forum as a guest. Join our free community to post topics and start private conversations. Please contact us if you need help with registration or your account login.

  2. "Muppet Guys Talking" Debuts On-line
    Watch the inspiring documentary "Muppet Guys Talking", read fan reactions and let us know your thoughts on the Muppet release of the year.

    Dismiss Notice
  3. Sesame Street Season 48
    Sesame Street's 48th season officially began Saturday November 18 on HBO. After you see the new episodes, post here and let us know your thoughts.

    Dismiss Notice

Your Thoughts: Sesame Street Old School DVD

Discussion in 'Sesame Merchandise' started by Phillip, Oct 21, 2006.

  1. jeffkjoe

    jeffkjoe Well-Known Member

    Hey Greg?

    How did you get an advance copy?
  2. minor muppetz

    minor muppetz Well-Known Member

    It's weird that Best Buy won't be releasing it. It seems like Best Buy carries every other DVD release, even ones that I can't find in other stores (when they come out). It's the only place so far where I've found copies of The Best of The Electric Company, The Weird Al Show: The Complete Series, and SCTV Vol. 4 (ironically, all of those are released by Shout!). And Best Buy seems to have a lot of Sesame Street DVDs to buy.

    Yes, fans want to see everything. I don't think every last episode and sketch will be available on DVD for at least a thousand years (by then most of the song covers will probably be in the public domain, unless Disney manages to extend copyright ownership again).

    Untill the last time I looked at the review, I thought that all three bonus celebrity clips from the first season involved them counting to 10. I was thinking, "why couldn't they have more first season variety besides having celebrities count to 10? Why not, for example, have James Earl Jones recite the alphabet instead of count to 10? Whenever I think of James Earl Jones appearing on the show I usually think of him reciting the alphabet instead of countign anyway." Then I reread the review and noticed that James Earl Jones is the only first season celebrity to count to ten, and the others recite the alphabet. I also wonder why Lou Rawls wasn't mentioned in the press release. All other celebrities who appeared in bonus clips were mentioned.

    One thing that I wonder. All of the episodes included originally did not include closing credits, and the closing credits for each season are included alogn with the bonus clips from each season. If a future set includes an episode with credits and a selection of bonus clips from that season, I wodner if the credits from that respective season will still be included.
  3. MrsPepper

    MrsPepper Well-Known Member

    I'm going to try looking for the set at Costco. That's where I got Fraggle Rock Season 2, so let's hope that this set is there! I can't wait! Great review.
  4. gbrobeck

    gbrobeck Well-Known Member

    I got it because I am a freelance DVD reviewer (having previously worked for several websites including The Digital Bits)

  5. Bein Green

    Bein Green Member

    Nice cover! Unlike...

    It is so awesome that the cover for the SS Old Skool box set shows the muppets looking the way they did during that time... wish I coudl say the same for the Muppet DVD(s)!
  6. minor muppetz

    minor muppetz Well-Known Member

    The Muppets Magic DVD did a good job at having the Muppets look the way they did during the 1960s...;)
  7. minor muppetz

    minor muppetz Well-Known Member

    Reading the review again, I noticed that it says that they are introduced by a cartoon character who explains that the episodes may not meet todays educational needs. I wonder why this needed to be mentioned. Do all educational shows need to have the same curriculum (I thought Sesame Workshop chose it's own curriculums for each year)? This makes me wonder if all previously-released Sesame Street videos somehow focused on their current educational needs. I mean, did Sesame Workshop teach kids about babysitting when The Best of Ernie and Bert was made? What main educational needs were followed for the other "best of" character videos (especially Kermit and Grover) and the two anniversary videos?

    Also, are the animated introductions annoying in any way? I would much rather just see the old episodes begin as soon as I hit the play button, or I'd rather see an introduction by a muppet (maybe Big Bird or Grover, or even the return of a classic character who isn't used much anymore, like Guy Smiley or The Amazing Mumford). Or better yet, maybe there should have been introductions by performers, cast members, or crew members. It would have been great if Caroll Spinney or Jerry Nelson introduced the episodes.

    While the review points out that the bonus skits are mostly stuff we've seen hundreds of times, there are a lot of skits listed that I can't identify any skit with those titles (like Swinging Gibbon, Alphabet Soup, and many others). There are also a lot of skits included that as far as I know weren't shown on Noggin, never released on video (in the U.S., at least), or shown in any new episodes in at least the last five to ten years (again, this is concerning the american version). Has the original version of I love Trash been seen since the first season? Ditto with I've Got Two (I have a feeling that theys topped showing orange Oscar skits after the first season). Out of the season bonus skits, the third season classic cuts feature has the most skits that I know and remember well.

    Looking at the still for one of the scene selection menus, it seems interesting that the Baker film for three is listed as Henson #3, instead of baker #3 or Let's Sing a Song of Three. I assume that the chapter stops also list the 2 skit as Henson #2. And I was hoping that chapter stops would refer to the skits by their official titles (if there are official titles), but it seems like most of the titles are pretty much made up. Yes, I am aware that older Sesame Street DVD chapter stops used titles that seem made up as well (Dance Along lists one skit as ABC Disco, but A Celebration of Me, Grover! features that same skit, but lists it as Alphabet Fever).

    Finally, is the Big Bird and Grover skit that replaced the store scene the same Big Bird and Grover skit shown on TV in E.T. The Extra Terrestrial?
  8. gbrobeck

    gbrobeck Well-Known Member

    Another couple notes. "Going to the Zoo" on the set is possibly the first Twiddlebugs sketch. The animated introductions might get annoying if you watch all 5 episodes in one setting, but they aren't too bad. They are very brief and humorous. Alphabet Soup is the animation where the little boy is fishing but all he catches are letters so he makes alphabet soup.

  9. Marky

    Marky Well-Known Member

    What's this 'Noggin' everyon'es talkin' about?
  10. BEAR

    BEAR Well-Known Member

    It's a cable television network. They used to play classic Sesame Street episodes until they were taken off a couple years ago.
  11. Marky

    Marky Well-Known Member

    Must just be in the States then, eh?
  12. BEAR

    BEAR Well-Known Member

  13. zns

    zns Well-Known Member

    Question about the episode introductions. Who is the animated Bob character? Is he Bob McGrath, Bob the Builder, or some other character that I've never heard of? :confused:
  14. gbrobeck

    gbrobeck Well-Known Member

    I have discovered that it was a character from some of the animations done for the show by Cliff Roberts. (Think Jasper and Julius.)

  15. minor muppetz

    minor muppetz Well-Known Member

    I've noticed that it seems like none of Christopher Cerf's contributions have been included on the set. I don't know when he began working on the show, but I think it was early on. I don't think any of the songs that he provided voices in are included (none of Little Jerry and the Monotones songs, where he performed Chrissy, are included, and neither are any Chris and the Alphabeat appearances, though I don't know if they had any other season five appearances besides Count it Higher). I don't know who wrote every song, so it's possible that some of the sngs he wrote are included (then againb, he specialized in rock music, and I don't think any rock and roll songs are included in this set) I wonder if this is a coincidence or deliberate (well, it's more likely a coincidence if none of the songs he worked on were in the episodes included, but I'm not sure about songs for bonus features). A lot of songs that he wrote and performed in have been released on video and DVD in the past (witht he most recent video production to feature performances that used his voice being 2004's What's the Name of That Song?).

    It's also a bit odd that Roosevelt Franklin only appears in a few cameos, and none of his starring roles are even included as bonus features. I know that he makes one brief speaking appearance, though I don't know if Matt Robinson voiced him there or not (on the Golden Age Cartoons forum, somebody said that Jerry Nelson took over the role). Regardless of voice, I don't think it would be a residual issue, since Matt Robinson apears as Gordon. I would be surprised if the DVD producers could get the legal ability to feature Matt Robinson and Loretta Long as Gordon and Susan but not Roosevelt Franklin and his mother. I would be surprised if Sesame Workshop was concerned about whether they are negative stereotypes, since some of the skits starring Roosevelt were shown on Noggin (I know that the season six premier has one of his starring roles, so if volume two focuses on the season 6 through 10 premiers then we'll probably see him more prominently). Of course, this set has the unedited version of the over, under, and around skit from the first episode, which Noggin cut to remove the black kid doing dumb things, possibly because it could be seen as racist, and that would probably be more likely to offend african americans than a major role for Roosevelt Franklin.

    It's also interesting that Professor Hastings is not included on this set, and he also wasn't seen on Noggin. I wonder if Sesame Workshop really hates him (then again, I've read that his skits are frequently broadcast in non-u.s. versions of the show).
  16. jacobsnchz

    jacobsnchz Well-Known Member

    It is okay...
    Not as good as I expected.
  17. theprawncracker

    theprawncracker Well-Known Member

    Augh! I've been calling all of my local stores asking if they have the set in store and they don't! Target, Best Buy, Wal-Mart, Sam Goody, NOTHING!! Grr! I guess I'll have to order it off the internet or wait and see if the stores ever get it in.
  18. Boober_Gorg

    Boober_Gorg Well-Known Member

    Did you check Borders or B&N?
  19. jeffkjoe

    jeffkjoe Well-Known Member

    OK, OK, one question has been on my mind, since my DVD hasn't arrived yet:

    On the FIRST episode, do they still have the old: "Broadcast in living color" tag at the beginning?
  20. Boober_Gorg

    Boober_Gorg Well-Known Member


Share This Page