Request widescreen Treasure Island and Christmas Carol DVD's
First, the good news: Buena Vista Home Video (a division of Disney) is planning to release the movies "Muppet Treasure Island" and "Muppet Christmas Carol" on DVD this year (June 4 and October 8, respectively).
Now the bad news: they are planning to release both movies as full frame (aka "pan-and-scan") ONLY, not in their original widescreen format. This has been confirmed by reliable DVD websites, such as www.dvdfile.com and www.thedigitalbits.com.
Why? Disney says that they've received lots of complaints from consumers about the "black bars" on widescreen DVDs, so they've decided to try out full frame versions on some "family" films. The two Muppet films aren't the only DVDs they're trying this with; the recent release "Snow Dogs" was full frame only and they are planning on releasing the successful "Max Keeble's Big Move" as full frame as well. However, other "family" films will be issued as widescreen (or in both formats).
But wait, weren't the other Muppet movies on DVD in widescreen? Yes, Columbia Tristar released the other four Muppet movies on DVDs with both widescreen and full frame versions. But "Muppet Treasure Island" and "Muppet Christmas Carol" are being released by Disney, a different company.
What's the big deal? A full frame DVD doesn't present the movie as it was shown in the theaters, since the sides have been cropped away to make the originally rectangular movie fit on your more square television screen. In the case of the Muppet movies, this will result in 28% of the on-screen Muppet wackiness being removed. The folks who created the movie designed it to be shown in widescreen; would you want to have paintings by Van Gogh chopped off so they fit into the frame you had handy?
That said, there are people who prefer the full-frame version, so perhaps it would be best if Disney released the films in both formats (either on the same disc, as Columbia TriStar did with the other four Muppet movies).
What can I do? If this matters to you, contact Buena Vista/Disney and them know that you want your Muppets on DVD in widescreen. See below for more information.
Can we really make a difference? Yes! Customer feedback on such matters has been successful in the past. Last fall, Warner Brothers initially released the "family" films "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory" and "Cats and Dogs" as full frame only; based on feedback from consumers and DVD fans (and some bad press) they released widescreen versions as well. Hopefully if enough folks contact Disney, they'll reconsider their plans.
Vista at 1-800-72-DISNEY, and send e-mail to
If you call they'll ask for your home address and e-mail addresses. This is to make sure you're a real person and haven't called 100 times before to say the same thing! Providing the information adds weight to your complaint, but if you're concerned about privacy, ask them what they'll use the address for before giving it to them (and express your concerns about privacy). You may want to consider including your "real" address in your e-mail as well.
When you contact Disney, remember:
What about a petition? There is an on-line petition asking for widescreen DVDs of "Muppet Treasure Island" and "Muppet Christmas Carol". Unfortunately, on-line petitions, while attractive, aren't very effective. Companies don't really pay attention to them since accountability and verification on them can be problematical. It's much more effective to contact the company directly. However, after you've done that, feel free to sign the petition - it can't hurt!
Contact Disney NOW and let them know you want "Muppet Treasure Island" and "Muppet Christmas Carol" in widescreen on DVD.