Here's my take on it... Pros: The jokes are funny. I've heard people complain that they're too pseudo-hip, or too "adult" (nipples?? Come on! Relax!). Pepe is funny, thought this "I'm so sexy" thing is his one joke through it all. Eric J. does a spot-on Piggy, and a spot-on Sam the Eagle. Whoever does Scooter now is pretty good, too. When the characters are finally in danger, you feel the tension from the muppet characters. The Tarantino scene and Jeffery T. both work nicely. I love that Piggy plays all 4 witches! The cons: Ashanti. Who? Why is she Dorothy? Am I watching 'The Whiz'?? She can't act. She's cute, and she can sing, but it feels like they were wanting Beyonce and had to settle for 2nd or 3rd choice. Poor Queen L. (whom I love) had to act with her, the beginning feels so... meh. Another thing I don't like in Muppet stuff is CG. Leave that to ILM! Now if you can get by the cons, I think you'd enjoy the DVD. It's a good rent, for sure. I quite enjoyed IaVMMCM - Oz is pretty much on par with it. Kemit's Swamp Years, I don't know if it was geared to 5-year olds or whoat, but it's kind of lame. And I wanted to kill that armadillo thing in the bonus features! So of the 3 TV films this decade I'd rank them 1. IaVMMCM 2. Oz (close second) 3. KSY. Recommended for the curious only!