1. Welcome to the Muppet Central Forum!
    You are viewing our forum as a guest. Join our free community to post topics and start private conversations. Please contact us if you need help with registration or your account login.

  2. Sesame Street Season 48
    Sesame Street's 48th season officially began Monday August 6 on PBS. After you see the new episodes, post here and let us know your thoughts.

    Dismiss Notice

Can we do something about posting for posts sake?

Discussion in 'Feedback' started by Drtooth, Jul 5, 2012.

  1. dwayne1115

    dwayne1115 Well-Known Member

    :o Sorry, I do agree however that something dose need to be done....
  2. Mo Frackle

    Mo Frackle Well-Known Member

    Yes, that's what I honestly thought the point of the thread was. But I will take partial responsibility for the thread's activity if others don't approve of it.
  3. dwayne1115

    dwayne1115 Well-Known Member

    The only problem with that though, is that it encourages spam in general.
  4. The Count

    The Count Moderator Staff Member

    Unfortunately, that thread has indeed become spam breeding grounds. Can't be sure of this, but the "I Think I'm Going Out of My Head" thread could have started up as a current version of the old "Random Randomness" threads, which again was done because the older threads got buried by newer ones.

    Actually, we used to have a system that combined what D'Snowths and Dwayne mentioned. Whenever a new member signed up, their first few posts would be invisible to the community at large, but any member of the staff could see them and approve or delete them, as said posts were in need of mod approval to become public. After a handful of such got approved, the member joined the community at large. Initial problem posts would be deleted... But if said member acted up, a first infraction would result in a temporary Strike 1 banning of seven days. When they returned, if they continued carrying out like actions, they got a Strike 2 banning of thirty days for a full month. And if they decided to return after that, still posting the same kind of things that got them the temporary suspensions, then it was a Strike 3 permanent ban from the forums.
  5. dwayne1115

    dwayne1115 Well-Known Member

    Well at least we know it could be doable, and was at one time. I think I had to do that as well when I first joined. I think that after the forum had that big update and the format of the forum changed, is when there should have been some new or jr mods instated. That way everyone could learn the new software at the same time. At any rate I have a feeling that after the newest Muppet movie hits the theaters that the forum is going to be flooded with new members. I would love to see the site as a whole maybe cleaned up a bit before then, but that is just me.
  6. The Count

    The Count Moderator Staff Member

    One word posts no big problem? Spoken like a true spambot.

    :news: In other MC news...

    UD: Muppet 6-Word Stories thread, now dead.
    Seriously... Posting Muppet song lyrics in six-word batches tag teaming with a second member, posting six-word messages that should be private conversations, and additional spammish stuff... Thanks for ruining another thread. :grouchy:
    galagr likes this.
  7. dwayne1115

    dwayne1115 Well-Known Member

    Now one third of the thread has been deleted because of that nonsense. How did I end up getting wrapped up in that mess?
  8. galagr

    galagr Well-Known Member


    Y'know, the thought of young girls having deep "admiration" for adult Muppets really does rub me the wrong way.

    You wanna know what REALLY gets me uncomfortable?

    A fan-fic (written by the same person, of course) about themselves getting pregnant from one of the adult Muppets that they "deeply admire".



    I am so done.
  9. D'Snowth

    D'Snowth Well-Known Member

    Ya know, I never did like Mary Sue/Gary Stu OCs where it's clearly the fanfic author creating an avatar of themselves so they can pair themselves in a romantic relationship with their favorite character of the opposite sex... but okay, for said MGary Stue to write themselves getting pregnant by their favorite character, that just seriously weirds me out, and I've seen some pretty freaky-deaky things among fandoms like this.

  10. The Count

    The Count Moderator Staff Member

    If there are pernicious posts, that's what the Report button's for.
  11. MuppetsRule

    MuppetsRule Well-Known Member

    I haven't read this whole thread but let me get this straight. Correct me if I'm wrong here. You are all in favor of deleting threads or posts that you deem to be posting just for postings sake? Who gets to make that determination? What's the criteria that a thread or post is worthy?

    For example, it was suggested a few posts earlier that the One Word Stories thread seemed to be just a way of padding somebody's post count and that maybe it should be shut down. Well, who gets to decide that? Maybe it seems like a silly thread to you but maybe people who are posting there enjoy it. There are certainly threads here that I roll my eyes at but then I just don't read them. I would never suggest they be shut down because I don't enjoy them. I just ignore the thread. Seems a bit arrogant or presumptuous to want to shut them down.

    Another example, I posted earlier in this thread a reply that read "I agree" or something along those lines. It was in humor because of the title of the thread. But it was deleted by the powers that be because . . . why? They didn't think it was worthy? It didn't contribute to the thread? Can somebody explain why? But this post was allowed to stand:

    It doesn't contribute anything more to the thread than my post of "I agree". And it was allowed to stand.

    Not looking to start on argument here. Just trying to understand why certain posts or threads are allowed and others are not? If they meet the criteria and rules of the forum then who are we to decide which ones are worthy or not? Muppet Central is a large community made up of a large demographic with varying interests. Why do we have to sensor posts because we think they are silly or not worthy?
    LaniArianna likes this.
  12. Sgt Floyd

    Sgt Floyd Well-Known Member

    If you ask me, posts made in the games section should not add to the post count. In almost every single forum I've been on, the games section never counts as posts.
    LaniArianna likes this.
  13. dwayne1115

    dwayne1115 Well-Known Member

    It's like I posted in the one word thread today, words like and, the , it before, and after don't tell a one word story. Now we have the ball rolling in the right direction in the thread again for the time being. I don't think the thread needed to be closed, it just needed some help.
  14. D'Snowth

    D'Snowth Well-Known Member

    The problem is when that's just about all a member posts: "I agree", "Yeah", "Okay", "Me too". I mean it's one thing to post such a thing in a joking/humorous manner, but it's another to thing when that's all you post, simply to post something, and again, we've had one member actually admit that the reason they post like that is simply because they like seeing their name in recent forum activity.

    It causes clutter, and who exactly wants to sift through thread after thread of a bunch of yeahs and okays? As we've said, if that's your only actual response to a post, clicking "Like" basically serves the same purpose.

    This isn't something new, it's always been something of a minor issue around here, I seem to recall years ago we had a member who was suspended because he had fallen into the habit of only posting, "Yeah I agree" whenever someone else posted in certain threads. Again, here's what the real issue is: when that's almost all certain members post on the forum, and that's what we have a problem with right now, certain members only posting "I agree", "Yeah", "Okay", "Me too", among other similar posts, and it's pretty clear that they are simply posting for posting sake.
  15. Muppet fan 123

    Muppet fan 123 Well-Known Member

    The entire discussion is a part of the fact that people were getting tired of receiving alerts and emails that someone replied to a thread or quoted their post with a short message with no purpose. (LOL's are officially the worst.)

    To avoid offense, no one made any comment to your post, but instead deleted it.
    Our continuous discussion is how the "I Agree" posts are completely unnecessary to this forum since the "like" button exists here. You might be familiar with many other types of forums, that don't have the Like button installed yet.

    As for the quoted message:
    "Muffining" (going off-topic) was always allowed. It usually adds more fun to the forum and gets everyone involved. It's one of the great aspects of this forum.
    I just don't know how to respond to a short mesage like "I Agree" or "LOL" or anything of that sort.

    I guess that's all I have to say. :D

    EDIT: Double Ziffle.
  16. galagr

    galagr Well-Known Member

    Well, I think that for certain threads in that section, it should count towards the post count. Hensonville City, The Weekly Survey, Game Suggestions Thread, etc.

    Maybe we should set a word count on each post. Replies under, say, three words will have to be made longer. Or something along that line.
  17. MuppetsRule

    MuppetsRule Well-Known Member

    I have to disagree here. I visit MC's forums every day but rarely do I post in many of the topics. I'm a huge Muppet fan but no where near the knowlegdable fan that many here are. I feel intimidated and much less knowledgeable on many of the subjects. Many of you are much more articulate in stating an opinion. So if somebody agrees with a post that says what they feel, what's wrong with stating "I agree"? And who are we to determine that that person is only posting for posting sake? Maybe it's a younger person who can't put in to words his/her exact feelings but sees a post that sums it up? MC should be a welcoming community and it seems that by deleting posts/threads we want to make it less welcoming and more of a closed community to only those people who we feel meet our criteria.

    P.S. And I know that it was suggested that instead of posting "I agree" or something similar that you can hit the Like button but this doesn't really convey or express ones feelings in the same way.

    And why should posts in games threads not count in post counts? What is so important about the post count that it bothers anyone what any body else's post count is? Doesn't the post count really matter? Is somebody with 1500 posts more important than somebody with 30 posts? No, not really. So who cares?
  18. dwayne1115

    dwayne1115 Well-Known Member

    Well if you would like to have some help with your knowledge, let me know and we can talk and I could maybe help you gain some confidence with your posts. I would be more then happy to help.
  19. MuppetsRule

    MuppetsRule Well-Known Member

    Once again, who gets to determine which game threads are worthy of post counts? It sure seems like a lot of people are trying to be exclusive. That's not what the Muppets are about.
  20. MuppetsRule

    MuppetsRule Well-Known Member

    Can't those people turn off alerts to receive e-mails then? Why should we exclude certain posts?

Share This Page